Thursday, December 02, 2010

Lemons - Part II

As we left this blogger yesterday, she was waiting for a loaner car to arrive and for some word on her mini-van.  I know my readers (Mom and Dad) could hardly sleep last night in anticipation of the outcome of this saga.  So here is the latest:
  • When the loaner car was delivered it was about 2.5 hours after it was to arrive.  The service manager (SM) called me once to let me know it would be about an hour and a half longer than he had planned.  I called service manager an hour after the second arrival time and let him know I had to be somewhere in about an hour and a half.  In the meantime, I told myself I should have asked for a red Impala, since they seemed to be so eager to please me.  Imagine my surprise when I heard the vehicles in my drive and looked out to see a red Impala.  Yippee! 
  • The executive service manager (ESM) and the (lowly) service manager proceeded to tell me they wanted to make things right and wanted me to be happy with my car.  The ESM said he'd driven my car.  "You did?, I asked.  "How far?"  He replied, "Not very.  We're going to replace the tranny."  We chatted about that for a bit and I pointed out that this would be the third transmission in my 2008 van.  I said I'd visit with hubby about that and let them know.  Then I called my readers and got their opinon.  Basically one said "It's a lemon." and the other said "Stick to your guns."
  • Hubby and I decided to have the transmission replaced with the "new" rebuilt transmission.  I'd been told the warranty on our car would remain the same with the same expiration dates (5 years or 100,000 miles) and that they don't have new transmissions for that particular vehicle.  They only manufacture as many as the numbers of the vehicle they were making and they no longer make our vehicle.
  • But the longer I thought about it, the less it made sense to me.  So this morning I crafted another email and sent it to SM explaining that we would let them install this "new" rebuilt transmission with one stipulation: we get the 5 year/100,000 mile warranty on it.  They're shorting me on the warranty and this is going to be the third transmission: a new one followed by a "new" rebuilt and the one they're proposing to put in my car.  The first two have conked out with less than 50,000 miles on them.  I'm not that sold on the idea of a third and I'm sure they could understand my concern.  I've also told SM twice that if we get a "new" rebuilt transmission and it lurches even once, the car's going back to them and we'll be talking different car.  Then I placed a phone call about an hour and a half later to get SM's response.
  • At this time, they are contacting the manufacturer's "fix stop manager" (FSM) to see if they can extend the warranty as I've requested.  It's out of their hands at the dealership.

Wednesday, December 01, 2010

Lemons

I hate dealing with car repairs, salesmen and dealerships. 

This morning my car decided it had had enough and would not move forward from an intersection just a mile away from home.  Not forward.  Not backward.  The only motion it had going for it was rolling down the incline, thankfully, because I did not want to be stuck directly behind the stop sign blocking traffic.  The car (a mini-van, technically) was not alone in having had enough.

We purchased this car in August of 2009.  By November of the same year we had it in the repair shop because it would lurch when I pulled away from a stop.  It was in again the following spring.  During one of those visits, hubby was told that they had replaced the transmission in this vehicle during their inspection process because they found it wouldn't shift into overdrive.  Important information.  Why hadn't that been shared with us during the purchase process? 

We'd take the car home and it would run fine for a few months.  The latest episode began earlier this month, when I was taking my aunt to a play in KC.  About at our destination, the car began lurching something awful.  Lordy, I was so embarassed.  However, I really thought it might have had to do with the E85 gasoline I'd put in that morning.  It had never sputtered and lurched like that before.  I made it home and immediately complained to hubby.  We filled the tank with regular gas a few times hoping to run out the E85 and just this weekend put some HEET in the gas tank.  Oh, those home remedies.  On my drive home yesterday, I began hearing an odd noise on accelleration.  Kind of a whine.  Today, it conks out. 

Hubby contacts a tow truck operation and has the car towed to the dealership and then places a call to the service department where he's told they'll look at it.  Oh, no, I say.  They're going to do more than look at it.  And hubby invites me to call the dealership myself. 

There are phone numbers listed on their website, but none for the guy hubby had suggested I call.  However, there was a "contact us" link and an email address for someone at the local dealership.  Knowing that the pen is mightier than the sword (and no one can see you cry when you type an email), I began composing an email laden with facts, concerns and my list of acceptable solutions to this fiasco.  I want a different mini-van of the same year; in the same interior and exterior condition as the one we now have; with the same mileage as the one we purchased; with a carfax report; and a loaner at no cost to us.  After sending this to both places, I called the dealership manager, where I left a very nice message asking him to read the email and call me.

About 45 minutes later, I had received a conference call from the executive service manager and the service manager.  The service manager said he completely understands my frustration and wants to be given a chance to fix the car.  He does not think we have a lemon and thinks the problems lie with the transmission.  (Duh.)  He asked if he could drive the car for a couple of days and get a feel for the problem.  He'd then call and let me know what he thought it would take to fix the car.  My answer was yes, that would be fine, but if this does not solve the problem, I will be asking for a different car.

The loaner car, at no cost to us, will be here soon.  Stay tuned for an update.